No, this is not clickbait. The idea actually ties into something called the Fermi paradox. Or rather, several scientific theories connected to it.
From the Wikipedia article I linked to, here are the guts and glory of the Fermi paradox:
The Fermi paradox is the seeming inconsistency between the lack of evidence of extraterrestrial civilizations and the apparently high likelihood of their existence.
In simple terms, the Fermi paradox asks why, given the vast number of stars and potentially habitable planets in our observable universe, there is no clear evidence of extraterrestrial civilizations.
In other words, with all the stars, planets, and galaxies scattered throughout the universe, why haven’t we found any signs of intelligent life?
Could it be that, just as the dinosaurs were wiped out by a catastrophic asteroid impact, other civilizations suffered similar disasters? Perhaps an asteroid, a nearby supernova, or some other cosmic catastrophe destroyed them.
Or maybe they simply destroyed themselves through war, environmental collapse, or technology they could no longer control.
And lo and behold, after billions of years of civilizations rising and falling, perhaps we’re all that’s left.
Now, isn’t that a scary thought?
Several scientific papers have explored this possibility, examining why intelligent civilizations might disappear long before we ever have the chance to discover them. Some investigate catastrophic events that could wipe out life, while others explore the possibility that advanced civilizations eventually destroy themselves.
1. The Great Filter: Are We Almost Past It? (1998)
Robin Hanson
Explores the possibility that civilizations encounter an enormous obstacle preventing them from becoming advanced, spacefaring societies. That obstacle might be behind us, or it could still lie ahead, potentially leading to our extinction.
2. An Astrophysical Explanation for the Great Silence (1999)
James Annis
Proposes that powerful gamma-ray bursts could periodically devastate life across large regions of the galaxy, preventing intelligent civilizations from surviving long enough to spread throughout space.
3. Prior Indigenous Technological Species (2017)
Jason T. Wright
Examines whether technological civilizations could have existed in our solar system long before humanity. It explores how geological processes might erase evidence of ancient civilizations and where surviving technological artifacts might still be found.
4. A New Empirical Constraint on the Prevalence of Technological Species in the Universe (2016)
Adam Frank and Woodruff Sullivan
Uses astronomical observations and the Drake equation to examine whether other technological civilizations may have existed during the universe’s history, even if none are around today.
Yeah, okay. With the different articles I’ve written and the research I’ve done, including Is the Universe a Living Organism? and Could Parallel Universes Actually Exist?, this whole idea raises even more questions in my mind.
1. What about bubble universes?
If bubble universes actually exist, are scientists talking about civilizations disappearing from just our universe? Or could this apply to all the other bubble universes, and perhaps even the granddaddy universe that contains them all?
After all, if there are countless universes out there, wouldn’t that create even more opportunities for intelligent life to develop?
2. What if the universe is a living organism?
If the universe really is some kind of living organism, wouldn’t it have the ability to heal itself and create new life?
Think about our own bodies. Cells die, but new cells replace them. Our bodies constantly repair and regenerate themselves.
Could the universe work in a similar way? Perhaps civilizations die out, but new ones eventually take their place. Maybe extinction isn’t the end of life throughout the universe, but simply part of a much larger cycle.
Of course, that’s speculation. But it’s an interesting possibility.
3. And what if none of those theories are correct?
Even if the universe isn’t a living organism, and even if bubble universes or some granddaddy universe don’t exist, we’re still left with one enormous question.
Our universe is approximately 13.8 billion years old.
We’ve already discovered thousands of exoplanets, including some that appear to have conditions that could potentially support life. We haven’t confirmed life on any of them, but we know that planets capable of supporting at least some of life’s basic requirements may exist beyond Earth.
So, really?
With billions of galaxies, countless stars, and an unimaginable number of planets, are we supposed to believe that Earth is the only place where intelligent life has ever developed?
Or is it possible that other civilizations came and went billions of years before humanity ever appeared?
Maybe we’re not alone in the history of the universe.
Maybe we’re just alone right now.
Seriously, I have a hard time buying this one.
Our own Milky Way galaxy is approximately 13.6 billion years old, making it nearly as old as the universe itself. With that much time available, I would think that if some universal catastrophe were capable of wiping out intelligent civilizations everywhere, we might have experienced it ourselves.
And I’ve already explored the possibility that our current civilization might not be Earth’s first technologically advanced civilization in my article, Piri Reis Map and Earth-Crust Displacement. Of course, that’s an intriguing possibility, not something we’ve scientifically established.
I can certainly imagine catastrophic events wiping out SOME civilizations throughout the known universe. Asteroid impacts, gamma-ray bursts, supernovae, or even civilizations destroying themselves through warfare or environmental disasters.
But ALL of them? Every single intelligent civilization except humanity?
Please.
I’d love to see someone calculate the odds of that happening. Out of all the potentially habitable planets, across billions of galaxies and billions of years, what are the chances that humanity would be the only surviving technological civilization?
I’m not saying it’s impossible. I’m saying I’d like to see the mathematics behind it before I’m willing to believe it.
Ok, I knew I couldn’t be the only person that went bull shit when this theory was brought up. Gadget(ChatGPT), my AI client just pointed out to me that a paper was written that disputed this paradox. Called the A probabilistic analysis of the Fermi paradox in terms of the Drake formula: the role of the L factor
So, the guts and glory of that research is that these civilizations didn’t all disappear at once.
Well, no shit, Sherlock.
I still don’t buy the idea that humanity could be the only intelligent civilization left in the universe.
Personally, I believe there is other intelligent life out there. And yes, I absolutely accept the possibility that previous civilizations may have been completely destroyed. Some through natural catastrophes, others perhaps through their own actions.
But consider the age of the universe, its almost unimaginable vastness, and the sheer number of stars, planets, and solar systems scattered throughout it.
Are we really supposed to believe that every other intelligent civilization that may have existed has disappeared, leaving humanity as the only one still standing?
Sorry, I don’t buy it.
Now, I can’t prove that other civilizations exist, and science hasn’t confirmed that they do. But until we have a better understanding of how frequently intelligent life develops and how long civilizations survive, we can’t reliably calculate those odds.
And that’s my point. The absence of evidence isn’t proof that everyone else is dead.
Maybe we simply haven’t figured out where, or how, to look.