The reason I wrote my previous article, “Are We Done Discovering/Creating Different Math?”, was to question how confidently we can declare something impossible when our understanding of mathematics and physics continues to evolve.
I wanted to follow it up with actual examples of how mathematics and scientific theories have changed what we understand about the universe. Ideas that once seemed unimaginable have become subjects of serious scientific investigation.
My argument was never that we will definitely discover new mathematics that makes faster-than-light travel possible. It was about the difference between saying something is impossible and saying that, based on our current understanding of mathematics and physics, we don’t believe it is possible.
That qualification matters. And history gives us good reason to be careful with absolute declarations.
Einstein’s Theory of Relativity: Changing Our Understanding of Space
Let’s start with one of the greatest changes in our understanding of space and the universe: Albert Einstein’s Theory of Relativity.
Before Einstein, scientists largely relied on Isaac Newton’s laws of motion and gravity. Those laws worked remarkably well and still do today. But they didn’t tell the entire story.
In 1905, Einstein introduced Special Relativity. Space and time were not the separate, absolute quantities scientists had traditionally assumed. Time could pass differently depending on an observer’s motion, and measurements of distance could change with relative motion.
Then, in 1915, General Relativity changed our understanding of gravity itself. Einstein’s equations described gravity as the curvature of spacetime caused by mass and energy. Massive objects could bend light, gravity could affect the passage of time, and disturbances in spacetime could travel as gravitational waves.
Think about what that meant. Space was no longer an unchanging background. Space and time were part of a dynamic structure that could curve and respond to matter and energy.
His theories became the foundation for investigating black holes, gravitational waves, the expansion of the universe, and theoretical possibilities involving wormholes. That is exactly my point: a new mathematical framework opened questions earlier theories could not adequately explain.
Wormholes and Bubble Universes
One of my favorite examples involves Carl Sagan. While writing Contact, later made into a movie, he wanted a scientific explanation for traveling enormous distances through space. He considered black holes and asked physicist Kip Thorne about the idea. That question helped inspire research into traversable wormholes.
No, we have never discovered a wormhole. And the theoretical conditions for a traversable one are a very long way from demonstrating that we could build or use one. But Sagan’s question helped push physicists to investigate the mathematics.
Now, here’s my question. If a science fiction author had never asked it, would that research have developed in quite the same way? The basic wormhole concept already existed. What changed was the question being asked.
Another fascinating example is bubble universes. General Relativity helped lay the foundation for modern cosmology. Later developments in quantum field theory and cosmic inflation introduced the possibility that our observable universe might be one region of something much larger.
In the 1980s, physicists including Alan Guth and Andrei Linde developed theories involving rapid expansion in the early universe. In some versions, inflation continues in certain regions while ending in others, potentially producing separate regions sometimes called bubble universes.
Have we discovered another bubble universe? No. Do we have direct evidence that other universes exist? No. But serious mathematical investigations gave scientists a way to explore the idea. That distinction between a mathematical possibility and a confirmed physical reality is important.
When Mathematics Doesn’t Agree
Another point I raised in my previous article is that our most successful mathematical descriptions of the universe do not always fit together.
General Relativity describes gravity and spacetime on large scales. Quantum mechanics explains matter and energy at extremely small scales. Both work extraordinarily well in their own domains. But when scientists try to combine them under extreme conditions, such as the earliest moments of the universe, serious problems remain. We still do not have an experimentally verified, complete theory of quantum gravity.
String theory and loop quantum gravity are two different approaches to that problem. String theory proposes fundamental vibrating strings; loop quantum gravity explores a quantum structure of spacetime itself. Neither has been experimentally established as the correct answer.
Even geometry has changed. Euclidean geometry was long treated as the natural description of physical space. Non-Euclidean geometries showed that other consistent descriptions were possible, and curved geometry later became essential to Einstein’s theory.
Does that mean mathematics is unreliable? Absolutely not. It means a mathematical framework can be enormously successful without explaining everything.
And consider this: Einstein depended on mathematical work developed before him, including non-Euclidean geometry, differential geometry, and tensor calculus. Bernhard Riemann and others helped develop tools that later became essential to describing curved spacetime.
Think about that for a moment. Mathematics developed decades earlier helped make an entirely new theory of gravity possible. In my opinion, without those tools, I seriously doubt Einstein could have produced his theory in the form he did.
So why assume that future mathematics cannot provide the foundation for theories we haven’t even considered today?
A Question I Keep Coming Back To
Look, I’ve been accused of being clueless because of my previous article. Well, I’ve been researching these topics for quite some time. I question parts of these theories and take the time to try to understand them. Why? Because I always, and I mean always, question everything.
Let me give you a prime example: traveling faster than the speed of light.
We’re told that nothing can travel through space faster than light. Yet distant galaxies can recede from one another faster than light because of the expansion of space.
Now, I understand that the expansion of space and traveling through space are two different things under General Relativity. Faster-than-light recession does not mean a spaceship can break the local speed-of-light limit. But isn’t that distinction itself worth exploring?
I’m not claiming faster-than-light travel is possible. I’m asking what we still have to learn about the nature of space, time, and the limits of travel.
When someone makes an absolute statement about what can never be done, I’m going to question it. And I’m not afraid to push back.
In Conclusion
I’m not asking anyone to abandon established physics. I’m asking them to recognize the difference between what our current theories rule out and what future discoveries might teach us.
Look at what mathematics has already made possible to investigate: curved spacetime, gravitational waves, wormholes, and even models of other universes. Some of those ideas have been confirmed by observation. Others remain theoretical. But the questions themselves have taken us places earlier generations could scarcely imagine.
Science is never beyond question. Science should always be questioned.
Not simply to disprove something. Not to ridicule those who disagree. But to further our understanding of the universe and, perhaps most importantly, to discover possibilities we haven’t even considered yet.