Text to Speech Advisory:
For a better and more consistent listening experience across different browsers, we recommend using the embedded YouTube player. It also provides synchronized captions so you can follow along with the narration.
The original Listen button remains available if you prefer it.
Today, I came across an article on CNBC titled “Former OpenAI exec has quietly built $1.5 billion startup, betting AI can revive U.S. manufacturing.”
The guts and the glory of the article was that a former OpenAI executive has created a startup company whose primary purpose is to use artificial intelligence to help rebuild the manufacturing base of the United States.
That got me thinking.
As much as I like the idea, I think the picture being painted is a little too rosy to be completely realistic. Don’t get me wrong. I believe this person genuinely wants to accomplish exactly that, and AI could play a major role in bringing manufacturing back to America.
Bob McGrew, a former OpenAI executive, envisions a future where artificial intelligence, and most likely robotics, will help automate manufacturing processes.
The AI models being developed are already being used by a military manufacturing company. So, it’s not as though the company he has started is nothing more than a pie-in-the-sky idea. There is already some real-world application behind his vision.
The following quotes from the CNBC article help explain what he is trying to accomplish:
- It’s a user interface and an agent that does for manufacturing engineers what Claude or Cursor does for programmers,
- When a design changes, you can retrain a human in a day — but it takes three to six months in order to change the automation to reflect the new design,” McGrew said. “We’ve built a software and AI product that basically allows manufacturing engineers to build assembly lines much faster.
- If your design changes very frequently, the only place you can really build your product is in East Asia, because you need an army of human workers who can be retrained quickly, and you can’t wait for automation to catch up,
First, let’s address something here.
The American manufacturers that survived outsourcing did so, in large part, by automating their operations. Now, these were pretty much dumb robots compared to what we are talking about today. But the fact of the matter is that our manufacturing base started down this path decades ago.
Let me give you an example.
I once lived near both a Ford and a Chevy plant in the suburbs of Cleveland, Ohio. The parking lots at these plants were enormous, built to accommodate the thousands of workers who used to be employed there.
But as these two automotive giants faced increasing competition from foreign manufacturers, they began automating more and more of their production processes. This eventually led to a smaller workforce.
And remember, these were basically dumb, repetitive robots that took over much of the grunt work involved in manufacturing vehicles. They weren’t making intelligent decisions. They were simply performing the same tasks over and over again.
Now, take a look at any modern machine shop. Many of these smaller companies support the larger manufacturers by producing parts and components. They, too, have automated numerous tasks through CNC machinery, 3D printing, and other forms of computerized manufacturing.
My point is that automation is nothing new.
From Henry Ford’s assembly lines to today’s highly computerized manufacturing facilities, companies have always looked for ways to produce their products faster, cheaper, and more efficiently.
The technology has changed, but the motivation behind it hasn’t.
So, with that said, let’s think about this.
This technology could make the United States much more competitive in the global manufacturing market. It’s not that we aren’t competitive now, but we are nowhere near as competitive in some areas as we used to be.
And this technology SHOULD help bring down the cost of manufacturing.
Let me explain why.
What used to be inexpensive when purchasing products manufactured in Asia and other foreign countries has become increasingly expensive.
First, the quality of life for many of these foreign workers has improved over the years. Wages have increased, working conditions have improved in many places, and the cost of employing these workers has gone up.
And I want to make something perfectly clear here. These are human beings, too. They deserve better living conditions, decent wages, and a better quality of life, just as American workers do. I’m certainly not suggesting that keeping foreign workers poor is the answer to making manufacturing cheaper.
Now, let’s get into what is probably one of the biggest factors in the cost of purchasing foreign-manufactured products.
Shipping.
You think the price of gas is expensive? Just imagine what it costs to operate one of those huge-ass container ships carrying thousands of containers across the oceans.
And it’s not just the fuel costs.
We also have international conflicts that can disrupt major shipping lanes, forcing ships to take longer routes. That means longer delivery times, additional fuel expenses, and potentially higher insurance rates.
All of this adds to the final cost of products manufactured overseas.
Then there is the turnaround time. When a product is manufactured halfway around the world, you’re dealing with ocean transportation, ports, customs, and the time it takes to move those products to their final destinations.
Manufacturing those same products here in the United States could eliminate or reduce many of those expenses and delays.
So, if AI and advanced robotics can help reduce domestic manufacturing costs, while also eliminating some of the expenses associated with overseas production, there is a real opportunity here.
Lower manufacturing costs, shorter turnaround times, and a more competitive American manufacturing industry.
And that is something I can certainly get behind. Now, I am going to repeat something I said previously. This SHOULD lower prices. That is our hope. But I will now get into why this may not happen.
And we all know that once a product has been priced, that price rarely goes down unless there is an overstock for whatever reason. Too many were ordered, nobody wants the damn thing, or whatever the case may be.
So, who knows?
Now, it’s time to take off the rose-colored glasses and address the roadblocks that I foresee.
First thing that comes to my mind is the startup cost for companies that will explore this new method of manufacturing. This will probably require new machinery or robotic lines.
Remember, I previously stated that current automation is pretty much done with dumb robotics. So, unless these existing robots can be upgraded, I just see this as an expensive transition for that reason alone.
And remember, most electronics, i.e., motherboards, GPUs, and CPUs, are still mostly being manufactured offshore.
Also, the actual AI required for these things will almost certainly come with a subscription fee. So, if you have a large manufacturing site with multiple AI robotic units hooked into it, that subscription fee is probably going to be based on the number of units.
That is the way it already works for companies. Hell, just look at the subscription fees for using AI Pro. You are already talking about a hundred dollars or more for some of the Pro versions, and those may have a user count of five.
A prime example of what to expect is a large office with hundreds of people using Microsoft products. They may get a bulk rate due to the number of users, but it is still a serious financial expense for these companies. Don’t expect anything less for AI robotics in manufacturing.
Again, substantial startup costs for manufacturers. Downtime to transition over to this new method.
Now, if it is a large company that already goes through retooling when it changes designs, this is a known cost of doing business.
But what about smaller companies? Are they going to be able to afford this? And if they can’t, will they be able to keep up with those that bite the bullet and just do it?
And we might as well look at the elephant in the room.
I don’t see this creating more manufacturing jobs. I don’t know if it will lead to downsizing like we previously saw with automation. But I just don’t see more jobs being created when those rose-colored glasses come off.
This isn’t going to happen overnight. But I do think it will happen.
Like I said, the automation genie has been out of the bottle for a hundred years. And AI has been around for decades.
Also, if we don’t do it as a nation, other nations will. That’s just a given.
As a conclusion, I will note that I have followed automation and offshore manufacturing for decades. I am 67 years old.
As consumers, we expect products to be cheap and affordable. But we also expect a living wage. And there is nothing wrong with that.
But the fact of the matter is, we get $100 TVs because it was too expensive to manufacture them here. The same goes for most of the other products we buy.
I have no clue if this will bring back our manufacturing base. I think it will bring some of it back, just like previous automation did. I just don’t know.
I also don’t know if this will lower prices. This is going to require a huge investment by any company that moves in this direction, and we all know that cost is never eaten by the company.
But the one thing I do know is that if we do it right, we will not be as dependent as we are now on other nations for the products we need to survive.
And as someone who is anal about this nation’s national security, this is the winning argument for me.
It would also be nice if we could do this with mining and other dangerous jobs, for several reasons.
We are so reliant on foreign nations for the raw materials used in all of our electronics. Mining is dangerous work, and it can also be harmful to the environment.
But if we can use robotics and AI to perform these types of tasks properly, without ruining the environment we live in, this could help secure this nation’s future.
Again, national security.